India’s New Medical Curriculum Sparks Outrage Over Omission of Transgender Rights and Disability Protections
In a shocking move that has ignited widespread criticism, India’s National Medical Commission (NMC) has introduced its 2024 Competency-Based Medical Education (CBME) Curriculum—with glaring omissions regarding the healthcare needs of transgender individuals and people with disabilities. This controversial curriculum, set to be implemented in the 2024-2025 academic year, has been slammed by international organizations and LGBTQ+ rights advocates for regressive policies that undermine transgender healthcare and disability rights.
The curriculum’s exclusion of these critical components contradicts established legal protections, raising alarms among health professionals, activists, and global medical authorities.
Outdated Ideologies in a Modern World
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and the International Council for Disability Inclusion in Medical Education are calling for the temporary suspension of the NMC’s recognition by global medical bodies. They argue that the new curriculum violates India’s Supreme Court guidelines and laws meant to protect marginalized communities, including the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.
Critics are particularly concerned about the reintroduction of archaic views, such as the inclusion of “sodomy and lesbianism” as unnatural sexual offenses in the curriculum, and the omission of critical transgender healthcare guidelines.
Curriculum Lacks LGBTQIA+ Protections and Disability Training
The revised curriculum makes no mention of the rights of transgender individuals, nor does it address disability training—a crucial aspect of comprehensive healthcare education. Transgender individuals, who face unique health challenges, have long been underrepresented in medical education, leading to healthcare disparities. By omitting guidelines for treating transgender patients, the NMC has failed to align with the standards set forth by global healthcare authorities and India’s legal framework.
Additionally, the curriculum’s new guidelines allocate more time to sports education—eight hours, compared to the previously required seven hours for disability training—further diminishing the focus on disability healthcare. Shockingly, the curriculum retains outdated terms like “gender identity disorders” and refers to intersex individuals as “abnormalities,” using language that harks back to outdated medical perspectives.
Regressive Language Reintroduced
One of the most controversial aspects of the revised curriculum is its continued use of queerphobic language. The previous version included same-sex relationships and cross-dressing as forms of sexual perversion. While certain terms were removed in the final version, such as “unnatural sexual offenses” for consensual same-sex relationships, other regressive concepts remain. For example, the curriculum lumps behaviors like voyeurism, exhibitionism, and sadism together with disturbing disorders such as necrophilia under one category—further marginalizing those who do not conform to traditional gender roles or identities.
These discriminatory elements have caused an uproar, especially given that the NMC’s 2022 curriculum aimed to decriminalize same-sex relationships and incorporate gender diversity in medical training. Those changes were implemented in response to a Madras High Court ruling involving the relationship of a lesbian couple, marking a critical shift in how LGBTQ+ issues were addressed in Indian medical education. The rollback in the 2024 curriculum is being viewed as a major setback for the LGBTQIA+ community and advocates for medical inclusivity.
Transgender Health Left Out Despite Legal Protections
The exclusion of transgender rights in the revised medical curriculum is particularly concerning because the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 requires medical colleges to incorporate trans health and develop resources for gender confirmation surgeries. The NMC’s failure to reflect these legal standards in its curriculum could lead to further marginalization of transgender individuals within India’s healthcare system.
Ankit Bhuptani, founder of the Queer Hindu Alliance, expressed his disappointment with the curriculum during an interview, stating, “It’s surprising that the government, which has actively discussed trans rights in its policies, didn’t include them in the curriculum. This needs to be corrected urgently.”
Bhuptani also emphasized that the government has shown a willingness to engage with the LGBTQIA+ community. He and other activists have raised the need for consultations to ensure that LGBTQIA+ rights are upheld in future curriculum revisions.
Backlash from the Medical and Human Rights Communities
This regressive curriculum has not only sparked backlash from LGBTQIA+ rights advocates but has also alarmed medical professionals. Many experts worry that failing to educate future doctors on transgender and disability issues will worsen healthcare inequities. As India’s healthcare sector continues to grow, these omissions may have a far-reaching impact, affecting how LGBTQIA+ individuals and people with disabilities are treated in both public and private medical settings.
Organizations like WPATH have urged global health authorities to suspend the NMC’s recognition until the curriculum aligns with modern medical practices. Senior officials from the NMC, however, attributed the reintroduction of outdated concepts to an “unintentional oversight,” further frustrating advocates.
Conclusion: A Call for Change in India’s Medical Education
The National Medical Commission’s 2024 curriculum has ignited an international outcry over its exclusion of transgender rights and disability guidelines, underscoring the need for a comprehensive overhaul of medical education in India. Without clear protections for marginalized communities, the curriculum risks perpetuating healthcare inequalities, leaving vulnerable groups without the proper care and respect they deserve.
As India moves forward, it is crucial for medical institutions to embrace inclusivity and adopt a curriculum that reflects the nation’s legal standards and global best practices. The call for transgender-inclusive healthcare is not just about updating medical training; it’s about ensuring that all individuals, regardless of their gender identity or physical abilities, receive compassionate and competent care.
This new curriculum marks a pivotal moment in India’s medical education system. It’s time for change, and advocates are hopeful that the National Medical Commission will revise its policies to create a truly inclusive future for healthcare in India.
#TransgenderRights #LGBTQIAHealth #InclusiveHealthcare #IndiaMedicalEducation #DisabilityRights #CBMECurriculum #MedicalCurriculumBacklash #HealthcareEquality